Into the Shadows · Challenge 2
Into the Shadows Challenge 2 Guide
Part of Halloween: The Game ChallengesStory Challenges
Quick answer
The exact Pitchfork execution variant is not confirmed. This page does not name one.
Weapon Execution
The Short Answer
During Into the Shadows, Kill a Cop with a Pitchfork Execution. Have the Pitchfork ready before you attempt it.
Your Attempt
○ Not started
Saved only in this browser. This does not read your in-game progress.
What Challenge 2 Requires
- Chapter
- Into the Shadows
- Goal
- Kill a Cop with a Pitchfork Execution.
- Condition
- Pitchfork execution · Police
- Scope
- Specific setup
- Target
- Police
- Weapon
- Pitchfork
Before You Start
Have the Pitchfork
This is a requirement, not a pickup location.
Know the named conditions
Target: Police
Know the required Story route
Open the Into the Shadows walkthrough for the required objectives. This page does not copy that sequence in full.
Open Into the Shadows Walkthrough →
How to Complete Into the Shadows Challenge 2
Each step comes from the Challenge wording plus named weapons, executions or places. This page does not invent a path the game does not name.
Step 01
Play Into the Shadows
What to do. Challenge 2 only registers during this chapter.
Into the Shadows walkthrough →Step 02
Have the Pitchfork ready
What to do. This Challenge requires the Pitchfork. The weapon page covers where it comes from.
Where to get the Pitchfork →Doesn't count
- Kills made with any other weapon.
- A different execution than the one this Challenge names.
Step 03
Target: Police
What to do. Kill a Cop with a Pitchfork Execution.
Step 04
Check that the Challenge registered
What to do. Mark it complete on this page or in the Challenge tracker — both read the same saved state.
What Counts for Challenge 2?
Counts
- ✓ Kill a Cop with a Pitchfork Execution.
- ✓ Named weapon:Pitchfork
Not required
- ✓ No named environment execution
What Fails Challenge 2?
Definitely
- A different execution than the one this Challenge names.
- Kills made with any other weapon.
Why Didn't Challenge 2 Count?
1. Did you complete the named action?
No: this Challenge only registers when the official wording is met.
Yes: continue.
2. Did you meet every named condition?
Check the numbered Challenge, the named target, place, weapon, execution or state. A weapon cinematic is not an environment execution.
3. Did you start from a clean chapter attempt?
If you resumed from a checkpoint or partial run, use a fresh Into the Shadows attempt as a controlled retry.
4. Everything looked clean but still no credit?
Then a tracking problem remains possible — after the requirement and a clean retry, not before.
Tracking info checked against Patch 1.0.2 · Sep 15, 2026
Where Challenge 2 Fits in Into the Shadows
Available during Into the Shadows.
Open Into the Shadows Walkthrough →When to do this
Keep active throughout
This condition spans the chapter rather than a single Story objective.
Do this before
Before you commit to an escape
Handle the police flashlight, Cop Pitchfork, Wallace House police stalk, and police-car Challenges while you still have room to set them up.
Keeps the same state as the Challenge tracker. This does not read your in-game progress.
Into the Shadows Challenge 2 FAQ
- What is Into the Shadows Challenge 2?
- Kill a Cop with a Pitchfork Execution.
- Which Story chapter is Into the Shadows?
- Into the Shadows is a Story Mode chapter, so players may also refer to this as Into the Shadows Challenge 2.It comes after The Babysitters.
- Do I need a specific difficulty?
- No difficulty requirement is listed in the Challenge objective.
- Why didn't the Challenge unlock?
- Work the diagnosis above: finish the chapter, meet the named conditions, retry from a clean attempt, and only then consider a tracking problem. Open troubleshooting ↓
Guide status: gameplay requirement based on the in-game Challenge objective. Tracking notes reviewed against current official patch information. Last checked:Sep 15, 2026.
Challenge2○ Incomplete
Didn't count?