Skip to content
● Halloween: The Game
I'm Stuck

Smith's Grove · Challenge 2

Smith's Grove Challenge 2 Guide

Part of Halloween: The Game ChallengesStory Challenges

Quick answer

Grab and Execute 3 Orderlies with bare hands.

Multi-target

Show the route ↓Why didn't it count? ↓Plan this chapter

The Short Answer

During Smith's Grove, Grab and Execute 3 Orderlies with bare hands. Open the matching guide below when a named weapon, execution or place is involved.

Show the route ↓Why didn't it count? ↓

Your Attempt

○ Not started

Saved only in this browser. This does not read your in-game progress.

What Challenge 2 Requires

Chapter
Smith's Grove
Goal
Grab and Execute 3 Orderlies with bare hands.
Condition
3 Orderlies · bare hands
Scope
Multi-target
Target
Orderly

Before You Start

  • Know the named conditions

    Target: Orderly

  • Know the required Story route

    Open the Smith's Grove walkthrough for the required objectives. This page does not copy that sequence in full.

    Open Smith's Grove Walkthrough →

How to Complete Smith's Grove Challenge 2

Each step comes from the Challenge wording plus named weapons, executions or places. This page does not invent a path the game does not name.

  1. Step 01

    Play Smith's Grove

    What to do. Challenge 2 only registers during this chapter.

    Smith's Grove walkthrough →

  2. Step 02

    Target: Orderly

    What to do. Grab and Execute 3 Orderlies with bare hands.

    Doesn't count

    • Kills made with a weapon.

    Best confirmed Story window: Grab the Orderly

  3. Step 03

    Check that the Challenge registered

    What to do. Mark it complete on this page or in the Challenge tracker — both read the same saved state.

What Counts for Challenge 2?

Counts

  • ✓ Grab and Execute 3 Orderlies with bare hands.

Not required

  • ✓ No specific weapon
  • ✓ No named environment execution

What Fails Challenge 2?

Definitely

  • Kills made with a weapon.

Why Didn't Challenge 2 Count?

  1. 1. Did you complete the named action?

    No: this Challenge only registers when the official wording is met.

    Yes: continue.

  2. 2. Did you meet every named condition?

    Check the numbered Challenge, the named target, place, weapon, execution or state. A weapon cinematic is not an environment execution.

  3. 3. Did you start from a clean chapter attempt?

    If you resumed from a checkpoint or partial run, use a fresh Smith's Grove attempt as a controlled retry.

  4. 4. Everything looked clean but still no credit?

    Then a tracking problem remains possible — after the requirement and a clean retry, not before.

Tracking info checked against Patch 1.0.2 · Sep 15, 2026

Where Challenge 2 Fits in Smith's Grove

Available during Smith's Grove.

Open Smith's Grove Walkthrough →

When to do this

Best confirmed Story window

Grab the Orderly

Do this during Grab the Orderly.

Pairs with

  • Pairs naturally

    Challenge 6

    The same Story event can count toward both Challenges.

    Open Challenge 6 →

  • Can be combined with care

    Challenge 5

    A grab can start without automatically failing the no-alert Challenge. Finish that grab carefully.

    Open Challenge 5 →

Plan Smith's Grove

Keeps the same state as the Challenge tracker. This does not read your in-game progress.

Smith's Grove Challenge 2 FAQ

What is Smith's Grove Challenge 2?
Grab and Execute 3 Orderlies with bare hands.
Is Smith's Grove the Prologue?
Smith's Grove is the Prologue, the opening chapter of Story Mode, so players may also refer to this as Prologue Challenge 2.
Do I need a specific difficulty?
No difficulty requirement is listed in the Challenge objective.
Why didn't the Challenge unlock?
Work the diagnosis above: finish the chapter, meet the named conditions, retry from a clean attempt, and only then consider a tracking problem. Open troubleshooting ↓

Guide status: gameplay requirement based on the in-game Challenge objective. Tracking notes reviewed against current official patch information. Last checked:Sep 15, 2026.

Challenge2○ Incomplete

Didn't count?